Mom lives in father's home with 3-year-old son, protests when younger brother proposes him, his girlfriend and child move in: 'I thought I could go back'

Author image for Ally Perry
Ally Perry • Writer and Editor
Jul 22, 2025 9:00 PM EDT

Money may be up there when it comes to common things that cause drama in families, but it doesn't have anything on property. A house in the family of nebulous ownership is all but guaranteed to start some arguments, not least when several different people are in need of a place to live. While the idea of being able to share a home between relatives can be nice in theory, most people are selfish. They don't want to compromise, even on something they are getting for free.

While it is important (within reason) that family supports family, this can get difficult when it comes to living arrangements in general. Some start to feel entitled to things they shouldn't, and others are forced to pay the price. Living with family members can also be difficult enough when you're growing up, let alone when you have adult responsibilities to attend to. There is a lot to consider.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    Sister won't let me move back in to our parents' house

    I'm a 27 y/o dad with a small son and my gf (his mother) We've been financially struggling for the last couple months and I thought we may go back to my Dad's house for a year or so while get back on our feet again. Context: I am the middle sibling of 3. I got a 26 y/o sister and the older one is 30. My parents divorced 10 years ago, dad left and started renting a place where he still lives to this day. He doesn't plan on coming back to the family house. My mother bought a house of her own last
    via rob1896-8
  • 02
    Cheezburger Image 10532696064
    via Helena Lopes

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Following a job loss, one man came face-to-face with this when his sister got upset at the prospect of him, his girlfriend, and their son moving into the house she lived in with her three-year-old, which was the former family home of their parents, where their father was still paying the mortgage. Having to get a worse-paying role than before, the man reasoned that it would be a sensible option to save money for a year.

    However, his sister was not happy and claimed that there was not enough space in the three-bedroom home. He felt she was being entitled, but he wanted a second opinion.

  • 03
    I just lost my job and I, as many people basically live paycheck to paycheck. I got a new job right away but it pays less than my last so I don't want to start acummulating rent, utilities, etc. I thought I could go back to my dad's house, so today I visited my sister and talked to her explaining the reasons why I'm planning on coming back home with my family and she went all crazy saying that there's not enough space, that she's good by herself. Mind you, it's a 2 floor, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
    via rob1896-8
  • 04
    Cheezburger Image 10532696320
    via Breno Assis

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • 05

    Commenters had mixed reactions to his issue.

    Guy YouMetOnline Only if she owns the house, which it doesn't sound like (and even then she'd still be being a ). I'd talk to whoever does; they have the final authority over who lives there.
    via GuyYouMetOnline
  • 06
    pastelcupcakebliss She doesn't own the place, so her saying "no" really doesn't hold weight. If OP's dad's okay with it, she doesn't get to veto. This is such "I got here first, so it's mine" energy. That's not how family homes work, especially when the actual owner isn't even her.
    via pastelcupcakebliss
  • 07
    SoftwareMaintenance Op could pull a reverse UNO and tell sister no for her continuing to stay at the home. "My turn now".
    via SoftwareMaintenance
  • 08
    LibraryMouse4321 If your dad owns the house, ask your dad if you can move in. It's not up to the sister if it's your dads house, unless your sister if renting it from him.
    via LibraryMouse4321
  • 09
    rosytwinklepuddle Family homes should be safety nets. She's pulling the ladder up behind her and acting like she built the house herself. A lot of siblings think that just because they're the "first" to occupy a family property, they get to gatekeep it. That's not how ownership works.
    via rosytwinklepuddle
  • 10
    entirelyrisky There's too much missing information here. Is she paying rent? Are you planning to pay rent?
    via entirelyrisky
  • 11
    rob1896-8 OP Nope, my dad has been paying the mortgage since day one which was back in 2012 and he plans to keep paying it until it's paid off.
    via rob1896-8
  • 12
    mickmun Can't wait hear how this one plays out!. Moving in with Sis who is entitled and doesn't want you there. What could go wrong?
    via mickmun
  • 13
    OrchidOne8324 I have to admit that I can see why it might bother her. Five people in a three-bedroom house is going to feel a lot more cramped than two people in a three-bedroom house. With that said, it sounds like it's not her house, so it's not her decision. She might have a right to object if she's paying rent... but it sounds like she's probably not. And even if she was, I'm still not totally sure that would entitle her to claim the whole house. If she's paying Dad rent... then that rent co
    via OrchidOne8324
  • 14
    BlueCrystalSnail I mean...no way would I wanna go from living with just my kid to living with my brother, his gf, and kid lol. Depending on the size of the house 5 ppl in a 3 bedroom sounds cramped to me. Not to mention she probably has the house set up how she likes, furnature and all that. But I have that luxury because I pay for my own housing and don't rely on the generosity of others. It's your father's house and your sister isn't paying to live there, so the decision is your father's.
    via BlueCrystalSnail
  • 15
    RockPaperOctopus Assuming she and her father don't have some kind of arrangement that no one else knows about, like she's been secretly paying for things and dads trying to save face then she's freaking out because she's become accustomed to her perfect low maintenance not having to deal with anyone low cost lifestyle. She's under some measure of delusion that it's her house when in fact it is not. Dad needs to pour a dose of cold water on her and remind her that it is THE.FAMILY.HOME. not her h
    via RockPaperOctopus
  • 16
    mygirl326 This is something that should be discussed between you, your father, and your sister. No one should make unilateral decisions that affect others. It's a 3 bedroom house. Your sister has 1 br and her son has 1 br. Your little family needs 2 brs. Does her son now have to share his space with your child? Are you and your GF going to request the master br because there are 2 of you and need it more? Is your sister going to be a reasonable adult, or is she going to be a SILFH to your GF and
    via mygirl326
  • 17
    DevelopmentFun3171 I would be upset too if someone came over and told me they would be moving into my residence - regardless of the financial arrangement with your father, it's currently her residence. And, I agree there isn't enough space considering you didn't even ask if you could move in your family, you popped over and told her / "explained" that you were moving three people into her residence. She clearly has/had an arrangement with your dad and the rug got pulled out from her feet. You ma
    via DevelopmentFun3171
  • 18
    BraveRefrigerator552 So would you be moving into just one bedroom? Or does she already share a room with her son?
    via BraveRefrigerator552
  • 19
    rob1896-8 OP She still shares a room with her son
    via rob1896-8
  • 20
    emryldmyst So you told her youre moving back in with two other people... you didnt ask. You're the entitled one.
    via emryldmyst
  • 21
    dedoktersassistente Exactly. "Hi sis, oh BTW we are going to move in here . Just so you know. Please make room for all our stuff" No wonder she is responding like this.
    via dedoktersassistente
  • 22
    Normal-Site-5194 Talk to your dad. Your sister's excuse (house doesn't have enough space) is absurd.
    via Normal-Site-5194
  • 23
    No-Professional-1884 Regardless of who owns the house, that is your sister's home. A home, it sounds like, you decided to invite yourself to live in without even asking her feelings about it. There's an entitled person here, but she ain't it.
    via No-Professional-1884
  • 24
    Cherique OP, please please consider this: I think space here is relative. Its not so much how big the house is only but that more people with different needs and styles of living will be living there. Speaking as someone who lived a long time with her parents, if people have different way of doing things and ordering things in the house, there will be arguments and fights. Usually the person who decides this in the average household are the women. And I can garantee, that the sister and sister i
    via Cherique

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama house family home aita move in kids brother girlfriend dad sister reddit thread Reddit mom son
Scroll Down For The Next Article